Can people with dementia live well in Housing with Care?

This week we hand over to Dr Julie Barrett who reflects on some of her work around housing and dementia…

image showing four photos of various views relating to housing, including the outside of a housing scheme, people chatting across their balconies, an outside seating area, and an internal eating area

When talking about housing for people living with dementia, the conversation often focuses on buildings: Is the design dementia-friendly? Is the environment safe? Is care available on site? These things matter, but research increasingly suggests that they are only part of the picture.

Perhaps the more important question is not whether people with dementia can live in Housing with Care, but what needs to be in place for them to live well there.

Housing with Care includes Extra Care Housing, retirement villages and other forms of supported or assisted living. It combines a person’s or couple’s own self-contained apartment with access to care, support and communal facilities. And people living with dementia are already an important part of these communities. My previous research estimated that around 23% of Housing with Care residents in the UK were living with dementia.

image showing three photos of the inside of a person’s apartment, including the kitchen area, bedroom, and living room

So, what is needed for people with dementia to live well in these settings?

Since 2012, the Association for Dementia Studies (ADS) has been exploring the experiences of people living with dementia, family carers, staff and providers across a range of Housing with Care models.

A home, not simply somewhere care is delivered

One of the great strengths of Housing with Care is that it can offer something fundamentally different from residential care: a person’s own home alongside access to support.

Research with people living with dementia has highlighted the importance of having their own space, belongings and privacy, while also having opportunities for social interaction and support when they need it. The ability for couples to remain living together can also be particularly important.

The real potential of Housing with Care is not simply that care is available close to someone’s apartment. It is its ability to bring together home, support and opportunity.

Independence doesn’t mean doing everything alone

Housing with Care is frequently associated with “independent living”. But we need to think carefully about what independence actually means for someone living with dementia.

None of us is completely independent. We all rely on other people, services, technology and the environments around us to go about our everyday lives. Housing with Care itself is built around this idea: residents live in their own homes but within communities where services, staff, neighbours and support are available. In other words, interdependence is not the opposite of independence. It is part of everyday life.

Choosing to live in Housing with Care means becoming part of a supported community, where residents draw on shared services, staff and one another as part of everyday life.

For somebody living with dementia, supporting independence might mean helping them prepare a meal rather than simply doing it for them. It might mean offering a reminder or some assistance so that they can attend an activity, rather than assuming they can no longer take part.

Perhaps a better ambition for Housing with Care, therefore, is supported autonomy: enabling people to retain choice and control over their lives while receiving appropriate help when they need it. Living well is achieved through interdependence rather than independence alone.

Dementia-friendly is about more than design

Considerable work has gone into designing dementia-friendly environments, and rightly so. Good design can help with orientation, mobility, independence, participation and safety.

But a dementia-friendly building does not automatically create a dementia-friendly community. People’s experiences are also shaped by relationships with neighbours, staff, families and visitors, and by the attitudes and expectations of the people around them.

This can be particularly important in integrated Housing with Care, where people with and without dementia live alongside one another. That can create opportunities for friendship, mutual support and participation, but it can also result in misunderstanding, stigma and exclusion.

Everyday acts can make an enormous difference: neighbours checking on each other, sharing meals, encouraging someone to join an activity or simply “taking someone under their wing”. Small interactions like these can be what turns a housing scheme into a community.

Staff and organisational culture matter too

If we think about Housing with Care as an environment rather than simply a building, staff and organisational culture become part of the housing offer too.

People living with dementia value staff who are available when needed, who listen, and who provide assistance without simply taking over. Research also points to the importance of dementia knowledge, person-centred care, flexible staffing and appropriate activities.

photo of a female member of staff supporting a resident

The whole environment, including its physical, social and organisational aspects, should enable people living with dementia to continue living the life that matters to them.

There isn’t one ‘best’ model

Should people living with dementia live in integrated Housing with Care alongside residents without dementia? Would a separate area be better? Or should we develop specialist dementia schemes?

The evidence suggests there is no simple answer. The DemECH research looked at integrated, separated and specialist models and found advantages and challenges associated with all three. Different approaches may suit different people, depending on factors such as their preferences, relationships, care needs, confidence and the characteristics of the scheme itself.

Instead of searching for the single “best” model, we therefore need to think about whether different housing options can respond flexibly to different people’s lives.

But can Housing with Care really be a ‘home for life’?

This is perhaps the most difficult question. Housing with Care is often associated with the idea of ageing in place. Yet we cannot assume that somebody who develops dementia will necessarily be able to remain there for the rest of their life.

Research has identified circumstances in which people living with dementia were denied entry to Housing with Care or subsequently moved elsewhere as their dementia progressed. Factors included increasing needs, concerns about risk and safety, and the ability of schemes to provide appropriate support.

This doesn’t mean Housing with Care cannot offer a home for life, it means a home for life cannot simply be promised by the housing model itself. It depends upon whether the care, resources, expertise, relationships and organisational arrangements surrounding that home can adapt as somebody’s needs change.

So, can people with dementia live well in Housing with Care?

The evidence suggests that the answer is yes. However, success is not guaranteed. Living well depends upon the interaction between several factors.

diagram showing six coloured circles grouped around a central circle. The middle circle says ‘living well with dementia in housing with care’ and the outer circles say ‘relationships’, ‘care and support’, ‘social environment’, ‘person’, ‘organisational culture’, and ‘physical environment’

We need to move beyond asking whether Housing with Care can accommodate people living with dementia. People living with dementia already live there. We should be asking: what enables someone living with dementia to continue living well, and to continue experiencing where they live as home?

Can someone maintain choice and control? Maintain relationships? Take part in meaningful activities? Receive appropriate support as their needs change? Move around confidently? Remain connected to their wider community?

Ultimately, we shouldn’t judge Housing with Care simply by its model, its physical design or the availability of care on site, we should judge it by what it enables people to do and be.

And that means creating not one supposedly perfect model, but a flexible range of housing, care and support that enables different people living with dementia to continue living well as their lives and needs change.

Thanks to Julie for sharing her thoughts and raising many interesting points for us to consider.

Connect with ADS on Facebook, Instagram, Threads, LinkedIn, Bluesky and Twitter.

Scroll to Top